The Roundup

A group of white-tailed deer running in a grassy field in the fall.

Photo courtesy of the IDNR.

Conservation Police Officer, (CPO) Fay received notification through the Target Illinois Poacher (TIP) Hotline with information of possible ongoing poaching in his District. CPO Fay gathered all the information and spoke with the caller who described in detail what was going on during the current firearm deer season. CPO Fay was familiar with several of the persons involved as well as the property in question. The caller was able to remain anonymous and CPO Fay went to work.

Allegedly, six hunters would hunt from tree stands, spread out in a tree line encompassing a 30-acre field, while other hunters would illegally drive deer from an adjoining property towards the awaiting hunters. The deer would be harvested, dragged back to a waiting pickup, covered up with straw and transported to a residential garage at a different location. The deer would be processed, then sold or bartered. The hunters would then repeat their system of poaching.

A hunter wearing blaze orange and camouflage gear sits in a tree-stand and aims a gun waiting for a deer to cross his path. The hunter is in a forest.
A hunter wearing blaze orange aims while waiting for a deer to cross his path. Photo by Steve Maslowski, USFWS.

CPO Fay enlisted the help of numerous other CPOs and a plan was quickly constructed. Prior to daylight, the officers moved into position to surveil the property and the actions of the hunters. At the same time, additional CPOs set up surveillance on the residence where the deer were reportedly being transported. After a long day of surveillance, during the last hour of legal hunting, the hunters begin to walk from a nearby residence, all wearing blaze orange, seemingly legal. Upon reaching their tree stands, each hunter removed their orange vest and climbed into a tree. As they waited, the ‘drive’ from adjoining property began as CPOs witnessed deer running into the field with hunters waiting. Four deer were shot by three hunters. As a group, the hunters retrieved the deer and transported them back to the house. After giving the hunters sufficient time to conceal their deer, CPO Fay and his team made their approach. At the same time, the CPOs surveilling the processing residence made their presence known with a warrant in hand.

A group of gray, brown deer stand alert in a grassy area. One deer turns around and flees the area. Evergreen trees are in the background.
Photo by Rick Wright.

Arrests were made and citations issued including, but not limited to: hunting without a deer permit, possession of another’s deer permit, tagging a deer with another’s permit, hunting with no blaze orange and participating in a deer hunt with no hunting license/deer permit. Also, charges were issued for possession of deer with no proof of harvest and the illegal sale/barter of deer meat. All deer meat and firearms were confiscated, court dates were assigned, and ultimately fines and suspension of hunting privileges were issued by the courts.

When interviewed, one of the hunters explained that the ‘rounding up’ of deer had been going on for a while, and admitted that what he was going through then was a serious ‘ROUND UP.’

Conservation Police Officers need all the help they can get when it comes to enforcing game laws and protecting our natural resources. Contact the TIP Hotline or call 1-877-2DNRLAW (1-877-236-7529) with any information that might help protect our natural resources. As always, stay safe and have a great hunting season!


Retired Lieutenant Eric Bumgarner spent 24 years with the Illinois Conservation Police. Eric is an avid outdoorsman and has a passion for protecting the natural resources.

Share this Article

Submit a question for the author

Please complete the verification below to submit your question:



Explore Our Family of Websites

Similar Reads


Three white-tailed deer are in a harvest agricultural field. Two of the deer are grazing. The deer in the foreground is walking towards the right with its head up. The deer in the foreground and one in the background have large antlers. A woodland is in the distance.

One Small Protein Worth a Whole Herd of Trouble: prion disease advantage in Illinois white-tailed deer


A adult male white-tailed deer with large antlers illuminated by a spotlight in a field at night.

A reddish young adult male white tailed deer with small antlers stands on the edge of a grassland.

CWD Management Program Changing


A raccoon peaks over a bag of trash in a rusted dumpster.

The Perks of Not Feeding Wildlife


A hunter holds a crossbow up in preparation for aiming while sitting in a tree-stand. In the background is a grassy field. Trees with autumn foliage border the field in the distance.

A black and white skunk walks along the edge of a gravel road next to a grassy roadside. The skunk has pointed its tail up and is looking to the left.

The Science Behind Skunk Numbers: What four decades of data reveal


A close-up of a black and white duck swimming on a body of water.

2026-2027 Illinois Hunting and Trapping Digest


During a summer day under a bright blue sky a row of tables are lined up in front of a partially roofed long metal pavilion. People stand on either side of the tables and engage in conversation. Various items and hunting gear rest on the tables and on the shelves behind the tables.

Make this Offseason Count


Dark gray tiny baby rabbits snuggled in a fur lined grassy nest.

Does That Baby Animal Need Help?


A brown, tan, black and white bobcat sits in a patch of green grass on a hill. Tan grasses are in the background.

What’s for Dinner, Bobcat?